by
CNN
–
Six years ago, two communities in New York – one in Brooklyn and one in Rockland County – were confronted with the worst outbreaks of measles that the United States had seen in decades. Measles were declared from the country in 2000, but 2019 brought the nation closest to losing that status.
Now measles outbreaks grow in West -Texas and New Mexico. Test locations and vaccine clinics are open in outbreak areas and the American centers for disease control and prevention arrived in Texas last week to support the reaction. Nevertheless, local health officials say that spread can continue for months.
In 2019, Swift, persistent efforts to curb the measles virus from the edge. The reaction was aimed at the unique needs of communities that were most in danger, powered by hands-on public health work that was supported by formal policy changes. Experts say that the way in which the outbreak took place in New York underlines the importance of an all-hand-on-deck approach to put the spread in other outbreaks.
The outbreaks in New York, which started at the end of 2018 and continued to exist most of 2019, were concentrated in Orthodox Jewish communities that had been the target of anti-vaccine disinformation for years.
Experts in the field of public health who were part of the reaction to the ground that building trust within the community was perhaps the most important part of their work, because it created opportunities to better use the most important available tool: vaccines.
“Vaccination is the most important way to prevent the devastating disease that can be measles,” said Dr. Neil Vora, executive director of preventing pandemies at the source, a coalition of organizations aimed at reducing risks of new viruses. He was heavily involved in responding to the outbreak of measles in 2018 and 2019 as US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention Employee that at the time worked from the New York City Health Department.
Two doses of the measles vaccine are 97% effective in preventing diseases, and the shot immunity is long -term. Because measles are so contagious, federal health agencies say that a vaccination percentage of 95% is needed to prevent outbreaks.
Thousands of people were vaccinated in New York during the outbreaks – at least 200,000 doses in New York City and around 30,000 in Rockland County, of which officials said that CNN was three times more than the annual baseline. Vaccin promotion impressions increased the rates in young children in the neighborhoods in Brooklyn that have been hit by the outbreak from less than 80% to around 91%, according to one study. But the process took time.
“We had the use of quite a bit of resistance in terms of getting people who vaccinated as quickly as we wanted,” said Dr. Oxiris Barbot, President and Chief Executive Officer of the United Hospital Fund, a non -profit organization aimed at improving health care in New York City. She was the health commissioner of the city during the outbreak of measles between 2018 and 2019.
“I think it took more time than we had expected, but that just really spoke to the degree of how hardened the disinformation in that community had become and where we fought against,” she said. “That is why it is so important to rely on familiar messengers to make it easy for people to be vaccinated and to have leaders who lead with the importance of vaccination. I can’t really exaggerate the importance of this. ”
New York City also benefited from a strong vaccine register that helped public health workers to identify people most in danger and make their efforts, said Vora.
“One of my great worries is that other jurisdictions in the country have not been brought in as well as we are in New York City, so if they are confronted with outbreaks, they will have even more problems than we had to get those outbreaks under control,” he said.
The work required a highly individualized approach, where employees are right on doors and make time to answer questions about vaccination one-on-one, Barbot said.
“There were certainly many people where we went to their houses to be vaccinated. There were cases where we essentially went undercover, so that their neighbors would not know they were being vaccinated, “she said.
The measles vaccine can quickly build up immunity – it only takes a few weeks to achieve its full effectiveness – and the efforts in New York have paid off.
A retrospective modeling study found that vaccination campaigns during the outbreak of measles in New York City have in cases averted an even bigger peak. The outbreak could have been at least 10 times worse than it was, with a maximum of 8,100 infected people instead of the 649 cases reported by the city, according to the report of Dr. Wan Yang, a university professor of epidemiology at the Mailman School of Public Health of Columbia University.
But as soon as an outbreak starts, experts say, increasing vaccination rates is not the only factor to consider. Findings from the study by Yang also suggest that “measles parties” – where children are brought together to deliberately spread the disease with the aim of creating immunity – accelerated spread.
Babies are usually most susceptible to a measles infection because they are usually not eligible to be vaccinated until the age of 1. At the start of the outbreak in September 2018, the work of Yang, more than half of the babies in the community, suggested, together with about a quarter of the young children between the age of 1 and 4 that were the second most sensitive.
The initial vaccination campaigns lowered by around 10 percentage points by around 10 percentage points at the end of December, and the efforts “seemed to be effective on the outbreak at the time,” said Yang’s study; Estimates suggest that any new case was linked to just one extra case at the end of the year, low enough to possibly avoid an epidemic.
But the chains of transmission grew rapidly in the first months of 2019, could explain faster than changes in sensitivity due to vaccination rates, suggesting that close contact rates had increased, especially in young children.
Out of measles are ‘dynamic’, Yang said. “It is not only sensitivity that determines how many new things you will get. It also has to do with how people treat each other. ”
Data shows that there were supports in the number of vaccines that were managed on certain important points: for example around the start of the school year, and when the city gave a mandate that children who live in certain postcodes are vaccinated to go to school or childcare.
This intensive work required a persistent approach, Barbot said. The only situation that required a similar amount of dedicated staff and time was the COVID-19 response.
In April 2019, about five months after the first measles shops were reported in New York, officials in both New York City and Rockland County declared a state of emergency due to measles-a movement that was also quite extraordinary before the COVID-19 Pandemie.
“The emergency statement gave us the resources we constantly needed to ensure that lack of resources was no reason why we could not end the outbreak,” Barbot said.
But official mandates and emergency declarations supported the more informal work that had already happened on the spot, experts say. Strong relationships that were forged between public health workers and trusted community leaders helped with broader communication strategies to expel disinformation about the vaccines, as well as misconceptions about measles that were a benign disease.
Dr. Blima Marcus, a nurse in the Bellevue Hospital Center, used her expertise as a care provider and member of the Orthodox Jewish community to enter into a culturally sensitive approach.
“I think the only thing that can really help is when your own community can find the means to mobilize and knock on doors, literally and figuratively, to reach people where they slowly change the story,” she said. “The idea that there is no one to ask and there are no answers to these deep vaccine questions – that is false, and [that notion] is part of what we hoped to change. ”
Marcus helped with the development of a pamphlet with information about the measles-Mumps-Rubella (MMR) vaccin that was distributed among around 10,000 houses, a plan that was specifically designed to tackle anti-vaccination messages that the community had infiltrated and to achieve people who were less tends to find information via digital media.
She and other members of the community knew that they had to be agile in responding to a rapidly changing situation – strategically tackling incorrect information when they occurred and concentrated on certain parts of the community that are most in need – and they often allow formal government systems.
“Even if you have emergency financing, it is not as rising as we really need,” said Marcus.
When the outbreaks were explained, Rockland County had 312 confirmed cases and New York City 649 had no deaths were reported by measles during the outbreaks.
The current outbreaks have not yet reached that size. This year, nearly 230 measles shops were identified at outbreaks in West -Texas and a nearby New Mexico County, with the first case that was confirmed about a month and a half ago and two people with measles people.
Much of the current outbreak is concentrated under a close -knit Mennonite community, which is confronted with a number of comparable vulnerabilities such as the Orthodox Jewish communities in New York.
“What I felt was very effective in making connections, forging in and, ultimately, in many places, increasing the immunization percentages is that cultural competent teamwork because people are aversion to hear what they should do by others who do not understand them or their faith systems,” said Marcus.
